Comparison

Shopify vs a custom e-commerce platform: which one fits?

For most webshops, Shopify is the right answer: it's quick to launch, reliable and there's an app for almost everything. A custom platform makes sense in a narrower set of cases, such as marketplaces, unusual catalogues or business models Shopify wasn't designed for. Here's how to tell which situation you're in.

Martin Balk Founder of Balk.dev Updated 6 min read
On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Questions to ask before you decide
  3. Shopify vs custom at a glance
  4. When Shopify is the better choice
  5. When a custom platform makes sense
  6. The middle ground: headless Shopify
  7. Hidden costs and lock-in
  8. Switching later, and how we'd approach it

The short answer

If you sell your own products to consumers through one shop, start with Shopify or a similar platform. You get hosting, checkout, themes, payments and a large app store, and you can launch quickly. Building all of that yourself rarely pays off.

A custom platform starts to make sense when commerce is your product rather than your sales channel: a marketplace for other sellers, a platform that hosts shops, or catalogue, stock and fulfilment rules that standard platforms can't model.

Questions to ask before you decide

  1. 1

    Who sells?

    Only you, or many sellers who each need their own products, orders and payouts?

  2. 2

    How complex is your catalogue?

    Simple products with a few variants, or configurable products, bundles, made-to-order items and stock in several locations?

  3. 3

    Where does the money go?

    Into one merchant account, or split between sellers and your platform, with fees, refunds and disputes handled per seller?

  4. 4

    Which systems must connect?

    Accounting, warehouses, marketplaces, suppliers or an ERP, and how much of that already exists as an app?

  5. 5

    What will it cost at your scale?

    Plan, apps, payment and transaction fees at your expected volume, compared with building and running your own.

Shopify vs custom at a glance

Shopify Custom platform
Time to launchFast, with themes and appsSlower: you build what you need
Upfront costLowHigher
Running costsPlan, apps and payment feesHosting, maintenance and payment fees
CheckoutShopify's checkout, customisable within its rulesYour own flow, for example on Stripe Checkout
Multi-vendor marketplaceNot built in, so you rely on third-party appsBuilt around it, for example with Stripe Connect
Catalogue and stock logicStandard model, extended with appsModelled exactly on your products and locations
Selling abroadShopify Markets for countries, currencies and domainsBuilt to your needs: languages, URLs, prices and tax
Lock-inYour data exports, themes and apps stay on ShopifyYou control the code and the data

Two details worth knowing: Shopify may charge an extra transaction fee when you use a third-party payment provider instead of Shopify Payments, and selling in multiple currencies requires Shopify Payments. Check Shopify's current pricing for the details of your plan.

When Shopify is the better choice

  • You sell your own products to consumers, through one shop.
  • Your catalogue fits a standard model: products, variants and stock.
  • You want to launch quickly and spend your budget on marketing and products, not software.
  • The apps you need exist and work well together.
  • Your team wants to run the shop without developers.

In those cases, a custom platform would mostly rebuild what Shopify already does well. If you're missing one or two features, a custom app or integration on top of Shopify is usually cheaper than leaving.

When a custom platform makes sense

  • You host shops for other sellers and take a fee per order. That's a marketplace, with onboarding, payouts and refunds per seller.
  • Commerce is your product, for example a SaaS that gives sellers their own storefronts.
  • Your catalogue or stock rules are unusual: made-to-order items, stock per location with reservations, or print on demand routed to suppliers.
  • You sell through several channels and need one source of truth for products, orders and fulfilment.
  • Apps and workarounds pile up until the shop is held together by plug-ins nobody fully understands.

Salestreak, our own selling platform, is an example: one catalogue with variants and stock per location, webshops where payments land on each seller's own Stripe account while the platform takes a fee, plus Etsy publishing and Printful print on demand. Read more about e-commerce platform development and our Stripe integrations.

The middle ground: headless Shopify

Headless means you keep Shopify for the catalogue, cart and checkout, and build your own front end on its Storefront API. Shopify offers Hydrogen, its own framework for this. You get full control over design and content, while Shopify keeps running the commerce engine.

  • Good for brands that want a custom experience on top of a proven checkout.
  • You still pay for Shopify and live within its catalogue and checkout rules.
  • It doesn't turn Shopify into a marketplace: payouts to many sellers still need apps or another approach.
  • You now maintain a front end yourself, so you take on part of the cost of custom.

Hidden costs and lock-in

With Shopify

  • Monthly app subscriptions that add up as you grow.
  • Transaction fees if you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments.
  • Workarounds for features that only exist as an app, or not at all.
  • Moving away later means rebuilding themes, apps and integrations.

With a custom platform

  • Building and maintaining checkout, payments, tax and refunds correctly.
  • Security, hosting and monitoring are your responsibility, or your partner's.
  • Every new channel or integration is development work.
  • You need a partner you trust for the long term.

Switching later, and how we'd approach it

  1. 1

    Export products, customers and orders

    Shopify lets you export your core data, which forms the basis of the migration.

  2. 2

    Map every URL

    Keep the URLs that rank in search, with a 301 redirect from every old address to its new one.

  3. 3

    Rebuild the integrations

    Accounting, fulfilment, email and marketplaces each need a new connection.

  4. 4

    Test checkout end to end

    Payments, refunds, tax and emails, with real test orders before the switch.

Our approach starts with a free intro call about your products, channels and money flows. If Shopify fits, we'll tell you, and we can build the integrations or apps you're missing. If a custom platform fits, you get a written scope and estimate, split into phases, starting with the smallest version that can sell.

Frequently asked questions

Is Shopify cheaper than a custom e-commerce platform?

To start with, almost always. Over time it depends on your apps, payment fees and how much you work around the platform. For a standard webshop Shopify usually stays the cheaper option; for a marketplace or an unusual business model, custom can be.

Can you build a multi-vendor marketplace on Shopify?

Not out of the box. Shopify doesn't include vendor accounts and automatic payouts, so marketplaces on Shopify rely on third-party apps. If the marketplace is your core business, a custom platform on Stripe Connect gives you full control.

What is headless Shopify?

Using Shopify for the catalogue, cart and checkout, with your own front end built on its Storefront API, for example with Shopify's Hydrogen framework. It gives you design freedom while Shopify keeps running the commerce engine.

Can Shopify connect to our other systems?

Usually, yes. Shopify offers APIs for products, orders and customers, and connecting them to accounting, fulfilment or a warehouse follows the same approach as the integrations we've built: authentication, background syncing, retries and monitoring.

How do I move from Shopify to a custom platform without losing SEO?

Export your products, customers and orders, map every old URL to its new address with a 301 redirect, and test checkout end to end before you switch. That's how you keep the search rankings you've already built.

Shopify, custom, or something in between?

Tell us what you sell, to whom and through which channels. You'll get an honest recommendation, including when Shopify is the better choice.

martin@balk.dev

Typically a reply within one business day.

Useful to mention

  • What you want to build, in a few sentences
  • Who is going to use it
  • Any deadline or launch date
  • Tools and systems it should connect to